Health & Environmental Research Online (HERO)


Print Feedback Export to EndNote
783954 
Journal Article 
Impact of exposure measurement error in air pollution epidemiology: Effect of error type in time-series studies 
Goldman, GT; Mulholland, JA; Russell, AG; Strickland, MJ; Klein, M; Waller, LA; Tolbert, PE 
2011 
Yes 
Environmental Health: A Global Access Science Source
ISSN: 1476-069X 
10 
61 
English 
Background: Two distinctly different types of measurement error are Berkson and classical. Impacts of measurement error in epidemiologic studies of ambient air pollution are expected to depend on error type. We characterize measurement error due to instrument imprecision and spatial variability as multiplicative (i.e. additive on the log scale) and model it over a range of error types to assess impacts on risk ratio estimates both on a per measurement unit basis and on a per interquartile range (IQR) basis in a time-series study in Atlanta.

Methods: Daily measures of twelve ambient air pollutants were analyzed: NO2, NOx, O3, SO2, CO, PM10 mass, PM2.5 mass, and PM2.5 components sulfate, nitrate, ammonium, elemental carbon and organic carbon. Semivariogram analysis was applied to assess spatial variability. Error due to this spatial variability was added to a reference pollutant time-series on the log scale using Monte Carlo simulations. Each of these time-series was exponentiated and introduced to a Poisson generalized linear model of cardiovascular disease emergency department visits.

Results: Measurement error resulted in reduced statistical significance for the risk ratio estimates for all amounts (corresponding to different pollutants) and types of error. When modelled as classical-type error, risk ratios were attenuated, particularly for primary air pollutants, with average attenuation in risk ratios on a per unit of measurement basis ranging from 18% to 92% and on an IQR basis ranging from 18% to 86%. When modelled as Berkson-type error, risk ratios per unit of measurement were biased away from the null hypothesis by 2% to 31%, whereas risk ratios per IQR were attenuated (i.e. biased toward the null) by 5% to 34%. For CO modelled error amount, a range of error types were simulated and effects on risk ratio bias and significance were observed.

Conculsions: For multiplicative error, both the amount and type of measurement error impact health effect estimates in air pollution epidemiology. By modelling instrument imprecision and spatial variability as different error types, we estimate direction and magnitude of the effects of error over a range of error types. 
NEVADA TEST-SITE;FALLOUT;ATLANTA;ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES;PUBLIC, ENVIRONMENTAL & OCCUPATIONAL HEALTH 
• ISA-Lead (2013 Final Project Page)
     Considered
     Atmospheric and Exposure Sciencies
• ISA-NOx
     Considered
     Cited
          1st Draft
               Exposure
          2nd Draft
          Final
          Final Cited
• ISA-Ozone (2013 Final Project Page)
     Considered
     Cited
          2nd Draft
          3rd Draft
          Final
     Atm/Exp Science
     Health Effects
• ISA-PM (current)
     Peer Input Draft
          Chapter 3
     Considered
     1st Draft
          Chapter 3
• ISA-SOx
     Atm/Exp Science
     Considered
     Cited in First ERD Nov2015
     Cited Second ERD Dec2016
     Cited in Final ISA Dec2017
• PM Provisional Assessment (2012 Project Page)
     Exposure Error-Misclassification