Health & Environmental Research Online (HERO)


Print Feedback Export to File
2467117 
Journal Article 
The role of social networks in natural resource governance: What relational patterns make a difference? 
Bodin, O; Crona, BI 
2009 
Yes 
Global Environmental Change
ISSN: 0959-3780 
ELSEVIER SCI LTD 
OXFORD 
19 
3 
366-374 
WOS:000269103900006 
Resent research has identified the existence of social networks as a common and important denominator in cases where different stakeholders have come together to effectively deal with natural resource problems and dilemmas. It has even been shown that social networks can be more important than the existence of formal institutions for effective enforcement and compliance with environmental regulations. However, all social networks are not created equal. On the contrary, the structural pattern of relations (i.e. the topology) of a social network can have significant impact on how actors actually behave. This clearly has implications for actors' abilities to manage environmental challenges. This review aims to add more precision to initial insights and pending hypotheses about the positive impacts of social networks on governance processes and outcomes, by reviewing and synthesizing empirically based literature explicitly studying structural characteristics of social networks in natural resource governance settings. It is shown that significant differences in governance processes and outcomes can be expected among networks experiencing structural differences in terms of density of relations, degree of cohesiveness, subgroup interconnectivity, and degree of network centralization. Furthermore, the review shows that none of these structural characteristics present a monotonically increasing positive effect on processes of importance for resource governance, and that favoring one characteristic likely occurs at the expense of another. Thus, assessing the most favorable level and mix of different network characteristics, where most of the positive governance effects are obtained while undesired effects are minimized, presents a key research and governance challenge. (C) 2009 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved. 
Natural resource governance; Social networks; Network analysis; Environmental management; Social-ecological systems; Natural resource management