Jump to main content
US EPA
United States Environmental Protection Agency
Search
Search
Main menu
Environmental Topics
Laws & Regulations
About EPA
Health & Environmental Research Online (HERO)
Contact Us
Print
Feedback
Export to File
Search:
This record has one attached file:
Add More Files
Attach File(s):
Display Name for File*:
Save
Citation
Tags
HERO ID
560708
Reference Type
Journal Article
Title
New vs old: descriptors can affect patients' surgical preferences
Author(s)
FitzGerald, MP; Elliott, C; Brubaker, L
Year
2008
Is Peer Reviewed?
Yes
Journal
American Journal of Obstetrics & Gynecology
ISSN:
0002-9378
EISSN:
1097-6868
Volume
199
Issue
5
Page Numbers
476.e471-476.e473
DOI
10.1016/j.ajog.2008.03.055
Abstract
Objective The objective of the study was to determine whether the designation of a procedure as newer leads more patients to choose that procedure over 1 that is designated as older.Study Design Women with stress incontinence read two 1-page descriptions of surgical procedures for treatment of stress incontinence and were asked to indicate which of the 2 surgical procedures they would choose whether they were going to choose surgical treatment. Randomly for half the participants, a rectus fascia sling was described as being a newer procedure and a mesh sling as an older procedure. For the other half of participants, a mesh sling was described as older and a fascia sling as newer. All participants were also asked whether, in general, they considered that newer surgical procedures were better than older surgical procedures and why.Results Forty-eight women of mean age 57 years (range, 33-82) were interviewed. Thirty-two patients (68%) chose the newer procedure, and 35 (74%) chose the fascia procedure, both percentages higher than would be expected by chance. When fascia was presented as being the newer procedure, it was chosen over the older mesh by 22 of 24 patients (92%), whereas when fascia was presented as being the older procedure, it was chosen over the newer mesh by a smaller margin. The great majority of patients (79%) stated that newer procedures are better in general.Conclusions Our results suggest that the use of the words newer or older may overshadow other important information that physicians intend to convey during surgical counseling.
Keywords
stress incontinence; surgical counseling; surgical innovation
Home
Learn about HERO
Using HERO
Search HERO
Projects in HERO
Risk Assessment
Transparency & Integrity