Health & Environmental Research Online (HERO)


Print Feedback Export to File
1010576 
Journal Article 
Hypothesis-Based Weight-of-Evidence evaluation of methanol as a human carcinogen 
Bailey, LA; Prueitt, RL; Rhomberg, LR 
2012 
Regulatory Toxicology and Pharmacology
ISSN: 0273-2300
EISSN: 1096-0295 
62 
278-291 
English 
Recent scientific debate has focused on the potential for exposure to methanol to cause lymphomas in humans. The concern stems from a few animal studies reporting an association, although evidence suggests the studies may have been confounded by chronic respiratory infection. Although the toxicological evidence for methanol carcinogenesis is weak, two modes of action have been put forth, one involving metabolism of methanol to formaldehyde, followed by formaldehyde induction of lymphoma, and another involving oxidative stress caused by hydrogen peroxide release during catalase-induced metabolism of methanol to formaldehyde. In this article, we apply our Hypothesis-Based Weight-of-Evidence (HBWoE) approach to evaluate the evidence regarding methanol exposure and lymphoma, attending to how human, animal, and mode-of-action results inform one another, tracing the logic of inference within and across all studies, and articulating how one could account for the suite of available observations. Upon comparison of alternative proposals regarding what causal processes may have led to the array of observations as we see them, we conclude that the apparent association between methanol exposure and lymphoma in some animal studies is weak and strains biological plausibility, and is better interpreted as due to confounding or to a mechanism not relevant in humans. 
Methanol; Formaldehyde; Lymphoma; Hazard identification; Human relevance; Risk assessment; Mode of action 
IRIS
• Formaldehyde [archived]
     Exposure Litsearch Jan 2012 - Aug 2015
          PubMed
     Prior to 2013 Search
     Nervous system effects
          Found
               Database search results
                    Web of Science
          Screened
               Title/abstract
                    Specific to other chemicals
     Immune Section
          Exclude - miscellaneous reasons
     Inflammation/Reactive Oxygen Species
          WOS
          PubMed
          Screened by Title/Abstract
               Not specific to Formaldehyde Exposure (other chemicals)
     Retroactive RIS import
          Pre2013
               Merged Litsearch Results 100912
               Merged LitSearch Results ToxNet 101012
               Merged LitSearch Additions 86 Reviews SCREEN
               Web of Science Search 100412
          2013
               HCHON tox Ref Identification 022713
               HERO Formaldehyde Immune Section 20Mar2013
          2014
               HERO_Formaldehyde_InflammationReactiveOxygenSpecies_pid_31_uid_5713Sorting091214
               HERO_Formaldehyde_InflammationReactiveOxygenSpecies_pid_31_uid_5713
                    Screened (Title/Abstract)
                         Not specific to Formaldehyde Exposure (other chemicals)
               Immune_HERO_allyr
• IRIS Formaldehyde (Inhalation) [Final 2024]
     Literature Indexing
          PubMed
          WoS
     Literature Identification
          Immune-Mediated Conditions in Humans, Including Asthma and Allergy
               Excluded
          Nervous System Effects
               Excluded
          Inflammation and Immune-Related Mechanistic Studies
               Excluded
• Methanol (Non-Cancer)
     Ramazzini
     Search 2012
          WOS
          ToxNet
          ProQuest
     Search Jan 30 2013
          WOS
          ToxNet
Other
• Ramazzini Institute